Baby checklists

Second trimester

Pediatrician Selection Checklist

20 items · 13 must-haves · Weeks 20–28

Questions and criteria for choosing a pediatrician

Research

5 must-haves
  • In-Network VerificationCall your insurance before falling in love with a practice. Out-of-network pediatric visits run $200-400 per visit. You'll have 6+ visits in the first year alone. Verify every doctor in the practice, not just one.
  • Location CheckYou'll make urgent sick visits on short notice with a screaming baby. A practice 10 minutes from home beats the "best" practice 40 minutes away. Factor in traffic at the times you'd typically visit.
  • Office HoursWeekend and evening hours are a massive plus — babies don't get sick on a schedule. Ask specifically about Saturday availability and how late evening hours run. This can save you ER visits.
  • After-Hours ProtocolAsk explicitly: what happens when my baby has a 103F fever at midnight on a Sunday? Is there a nurse hotline? An on-call doctor? Or do they just say "go to the ER"? This answer matters a lot.
  • Hospital AffiliationIf baby needs to be hospitalized, your pediatrician should have privileges at a hospital with a pediatric unit near you. Ask which hospital and check that it's in your insurance network too.
  • Reviews ReadOPTIONALCheck Google, Healthgrades, and Zocdoc reviews. Focus on recent reviews (last 12 months). Look for patterns: long waits, dismissive behavior, or great communication. One bad review is noise; ten is a signal.
  • Multiple ProvidersOPTIONALGroup practices mean your preferred doctor may not always be available. Ask: will I mostly see the same doctor? What happens if my doctor is out? Consistency matters for tracking your baby's development.
  • Lab ServicesOPTIONALOn-site lab for blood draws and quick tests saves a separate trip with a screaming baby. Ask if they can do strep tests, flu tests, and basic bloodwork in-office. This is a nice-to-have, not a must.

Interview

5 must-haves
  • Meet and Greet ScheduledMost practices offer free prenatal meet-and-greet visits in the third trimester. Schedule 2-3 at different practices. Ask your questions, watch how the doctor interacts, and trust your gut.
  • Vaccine PhilosophyThis is a make-or-break question. You want a doctor who follows the AAP-recommended vaccine schedule. Ask directly and gauge their conviction. A wishy-washy answer here is a red flag.
  • Breastfeeding SupportDoes the practice have lactation consultants on staff or strong referral relationships? Early breastfeeding issues need same-week support, not a 3-week waitlist. This matters most in the first month.
  • Communication StyleDoes the doctor listen without rushing? Do they explain things clearly? Will they spend time on "dumb" questions? The best pediatrician is one who makes you feel like no question is too small.
  • Wait TimesOPTIONALAsk about typical wait times for both well visits and sick visits. 15-20 minutes is normal; 45+ minutes consistently means they're overbooked. Also ask about a separate sick waiting room to reduce infection spread.
  • Staff FriendlinessOPTIONALFriendly, competent front desk staff make a stressful sick visit bearable. Rude or disorganized admin staff means scheduling nightmares and billing issues. Judge the office as a whole, not just the doctor.
  • Same-Day Sick VisitsCan they see your baby the same day when something urgent comes up? A practice that books 2-3 weeks out for sick visits isn't practical. You need same-day or next-day availability for acute issues.
  • Electronic RecordsOPTIONALA patient portal for messaging, lab results, vaccine records, and appointment scheduling is table stakes in 2026. If they're still fax-only, that's a sign the practice hasn't modernized.
  • Specialist ReferralsOPTIONALAt some point your baby may need a dermatologist, allergist, or developmental specialist. A well-connected pediatrician gets you fast referrals to trusted colleagues instead of a cold call to a random name.

Decision

3 must-haves
  • Final Selection MadeOnce you pick a pediatrician, notify your hospital/birthing center so they can send birth records directly. Call the practice to officially register as a patient before delivery.
  • Newborn Visit ScheduledSchedule within 3-5 days of birth. They check weight (expect 5-7% loss — more than 10% is a concern), jaundice levels, and feeding. Write down questions in advance — you will forget them otherwise.
  • Records TransferConfirm with both the hospital and the pediatrician's office that records will transfer automatically after birth. Follow up on day 2 to verify it happened. Lost records delay your newborn's first visit.

Check it off together

Make a free account to tick items off as you go. Your partner sees the same list, ticks included.

Get started freeFree plan, no card needed